Get A Free Consultation

With NJ’s Best Personal Injury Legal Team.

Call Now 📞


Is Super Lawyers Legit? (What You Must Know)

Is super lawyers legit - person researching super lawyers on a laptop, symbolizing the evaluation of its legitimacy and credibility

Super Lawyers is a legitimate rating service that selects outstanding lawyers from various practice areas based on a rigorous, multiphase selection process involving peer nominations, evaluations, and independent research. However, while it’s a respected resource, it’s always advisable to consider multiple factors and conduct personal research when choosing a lawyer.

Read on to learn more.

What Is Super Lawyers?

Super lawyers magazine, highlighting the prestige of being featured in such a publication

Super Lawyers is a highly respected rating service that honors outstanding attorneys from over 70 practice areas.

This exclusive list, known as the Super Lawyers list, acknowledges those who have attained a high level of professional achievement and peer recognition. Intensely scrutinized through a patented, multiphase selection process, only the most deserving are awarded the “Super Lawyer” title.

One noteworthy segment of Super Lawyers is the “Rising Star” category, which celebrates up-and-coming attorneys who are either 40 years old or younger or have been practicing for 10 years or less.

Law firms are encouraged to nominate talent for both Super Lawyers and Rising Stars, but the final selection hinges on independent research into each nominee’s achievements and common observations from peers across their practice areas.

This thorough vetting, known as the Super Lawyers selection process, ensures that only the most esteemed attorneys are selected for The Super Lawyers list.

The Selection Process

Diverse group of lawyers holding a super lawyers certificate in a meeting, representing professional collaboration and success

In pursuit of acknowledging outstanding law practitioners, the process kicks off when lawyers bearing a high degree of peer recognition and professional achievement are nominated.

The factor under consideration is not merely the numerical strength of nominations received, but an evaluation is performed by independent research of objective indicators.

This thorough, patented multiphase process entails scrutiny of indicators including verdicts/settlements, experience, honors/awards, special licenses/certifications, position within the law firm, bar or other professional activity, pro bono and community service, scholarly lectures/writings, education/employment background, and other outstanding achievements.

Fascinatingly, no more than 5% of attorneys in each state are selected for inclusion in Super Lawyers, signifying the immense prestige associated with this recognition.

Furthermore, a ‘Rising Stars list’ is maintained to highlight pioneers in law who are either 40 years old or younger or have been in practice for 10 years or less, of which only up to 2.5 percent of the lawyers in a given state are included.

The final list of lawyers is published on as well as in Super Lawyers Magazine, which not only elevates the professional stature of the selected lawyers but also boosts their Search Engine Optimization (SEO) capabilities.

Legitimacy and Recognition

Professional lawyer's office with a super lawyers award, symbolizing credibility and recognition in the legal field

A factor that cements the Super Lawyers’ reputation is the emphasis it places on peer recognition and professional achievement.

These foundational principles have created a reliable platform where top attorneys can gain increased visibility.

The Super Lawyers also conduct independent research, ensuring the selection of attorneys is a merit-based process, undertaken meticulously, thereby building trust amongst potential clients.

An added credential to its robust reputation is the assessment by a blue ribbon panel, further validating the competency of lawyers listed as Super Lawyers.

Reaching out to the tech-savvy generation, Super Lawyers harnesses the capabilities of digital marketing for select attorneys who are under 40 years old.

By unlocking new avenues of visibility and recognition, they are effectively securing patent references in the virtual world.

This offering creates not only brand recognition but also generates trust among the new generation of potential clients, making Super Lawyers a preferred site for finding top attorneys.

The effective blend of traditional methods of recognition with modern digital marketing strategies further enhances its legitimacy.

Pros and Cons of Super Lawyers

Early in the selection process, Super Lawyers compile nominations from the attorneys’ peers and conduct independent research for hearty evaluation.

The initial informal nomination process cuts across all firm sizes and encompasses more than 70 practice areas.

Subsequently, candidates who have been practicing for 10 years or less and those who have gained incredible achievements during their practice period are given extra acknowledgment for their contributions.

This point value system not only asserts Super Lawyers’ robust selection criteria but also acts as an indicator of the attorneys’ professional prowess.

However, challenges surface when one begins to ponder the essence of Super Lawyers. The top results in the search arena typical to the internet age are attorneys selected by Super Lawyers, which might cause bias in the eyes of potential clients.

Another criticism leveled against Super Lawyers is the possibility of manipulating the nomination process due to its partially informal nature.

Hence, consumers and lawyers alike should exercise due diligence and not solely rely on the selections as the ultimate badge of competency.

Super Lawyers vs. Other Directories

Satisfied client shaking hands with a lawyer who has a super lawyers badge, in a professional office setting

Super Lawyers uses a detailed, multiphasic selection process to create a credible, comprehensive directory that features only the top-rated attorneys.

Such a process involves peer nominations and independent research across 12 indicators of peer recognition and professional achievement.

Indicators include verdicts/settlements, experience, honors/awards, special licenses/certifications, etc. Attorneys who receive the highest point totals during this selection process are further recognized in the Super Lawyers Top Lists.

To be selected for inclusion in Super Lawyers is indeed a significant commendation only 5% of lawyers in each state can receive annually.

Similarly, one of the quintessential aspects that distinguishes Super Lawyers from others is the exclusivity of its recognition.

The right to display a Super Lawyers badge or to boast the Super Lawyers designation is conferred only upon those who have undergone the right process to become a Super Lawyer.

This not only elevates the badge holders above their peers but also reassures clients that they are choosing from the state’s most proficient and reputable lawyers.

At the same time, the Super Lawyers award further fuels the competitive spirit amongst legal professionals to consistently work towards excellent client representation and peer recognition.

The Impact on SEO

It is an undeniable fact that “super lawyers” is a rating service for outstanding lawyers from more than 70 practice areas.

This rating is indeed prestigious, as it recognizes only those who have attained a high degree of peer recognition and professional achievement.

When you add this badge to your website, it can enhance your website’s visibility because search engines acknowledge the credibility of such legal directory affiliations.

This can provide an impressive uplift to your Search Engine Optimization (SEO) and hence attract more potential clients to your site.

Shifting the spotlight to the adverse end of the spectrum, it’s important to understand the truth about “super lawyers” and their impact on SEO.

While “super lawyers and rising stars” are significant ratings, they encompass less than 5% of the total lawyers in the state.

Thus, it might lead to misinterpretation that other lawyers lacking this accolade are not competent, which is far from accurate.

Hence, while presenting an “outstanding lawyer” as a “super” one based on the rating, one should maintain a balance to avoid any inadvertent keyword over-optimization or misrepresentation.

As legal professionals considering marketing solutions, it is paramount to evaluate the ethical implications associated with choosing to advertise on Super Lawyers.

The distinction of this rating service lies not just in its coveted title, but also in its patented selection process. This operation takes into careful account the highest point totals obtained from nominations, research, and peer evaluations, to form a diverse and credible list of candidates.

Thus, understanding this process maintains the integrity of the lawyer ratings, creating a beneficent environment for both lawyers and clients.

Furthermore, with the prominence of digital platforms, a key ethical consideration revolves around the use of the Super Lawyers website as a tool for enhancing visibility via search engine optimization (SEO).

However, the question of ethical relevance arises when using this as a marketing solution; the ideal is to highlight genuine achievement rather than manipulate SEO for an undeserved advantage.

Specifically regarding the ‘Rising Stars’ selection process, the initiative must be used accurately to represent the qualifications of a young lawyer, rather than as a mere tool for marketing.

These ethical concerns, though intricate, steer us towards a healthier culture within the legal profession.

Personal Experiences and Opinions

Lawyers answer to several standards of professional achievement in their legal practice, such as meeting the 12 indicators of peer recognition – a criterion the attorney must fulfill to be listed in the Super Lawyers directory.

Besides professional accolades, it’s the recognition from their peers and the trust they earn from the clients they serve that mark their reputation.

Super Lawyers is a rating service that upholds these standards, wherein selected attorneys are solicited to serve on a blue-ribbon panel to evaluate their peers.

Clients, on the other hand, find that having a Super Lawyer is a great asset when they need legal support.

Based on testimonies, attorneys listed in Super Lawyers are often retained by the public, highlighting the directory’s credibility.

Furthermore, many lawyers for a car accident vying for a spot in various directories, including the Super Lawyers rating service, have expressed their satisfaction on a scale of one to five, confirming its significance in the legal world.

The prestige that comes with such recognition often translates to the lawyer’s efficiency in their practice.

Making the Decision

The decision to engage with Super Lawyers as a rating service for lawyers carries significant weight, largely due to its intended delineation of top-tier attorneys who meet ethical standards.

This is true whether a legal professional is considering leveraging this service for their brand, or a marketing agency is deliberating its impact on a client’s reputation.

It’s vital, however, to thoroughly evaluate the mechanism for scoring and assessing the legitimacy of Super Lawyers, keeping in mind the credibility imbued by the ‘Super Lawyers’ title.

The platform classifies a certain percentage of the total lawyers into two categories – Super Lawyers and Rising Stars.

The latter recognizes lawyers who are 40 years old or younger, or who have been in practice for up to 10 years, reflecting the platform’s commitment to the Rising Stars eligibility.

Lawyers who are considered for Rising Stars go through the Rising Stars selection process, which mirrors the one for Super Lawyers.

This duality gives potential candidates the flexibility to find a category that best matches their professional situation and aspirations, further solidifying the legitimacy of Super Lawyers.

The evolving landscape of legal recognition illuminates an intriguing trajectory where ‘super lawyers marketing’ is gradually gaining prominence.

This advancement is due to a shift in nomination trends that could potentially transform the recognition paradigm.

Traditionally, a select group of lawyers within a state are selected, embodying the crème de la crème of legal proficiency.

The eventual selection culminates in a published list of the top lawyers who have demonstrated excellence in the legal profession.

These selected accident attorneys undergo a patented multiphase selection process, ensuring their aptitude is accurately reflected.

Nonetheless, a rising concern within the industry pertains to talented lawyers who may be overlooked in the nomination process.

While some discredit this issue, arguing that the selection process’s merit-based nature inherently distinguishes the legal profession’s elite.

Others, however, opt for a more inclusive approach, suggesting augmenting the selection process to incorporate a larger pool of potential candidates.

As such, the future of legal recognition may revolve around a more objective and comprehensive assessment of the competencies and potentials of an attorney, assuring that those deserving of such high esteem do not fall through the cracks.

Contact Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez, and Fattell for a FREE consultation.
Our dedicated team is ready to fight for your rights.

Start typing and press Enter to search