Can You Sue Police for Negligence? Your Legal Rights Explained

Answer: Yes, you can sue police departments and individual officers for negligence under certain circumstances through a civil rights lawsuit or tort claim. These cases typically involve violations of constitutional rights or failure to perform official duties that result in harm, making it possible to sue for police brutality.
Understanding your legal rights when dealing with law enforcement misconduct isn’t always straightforward. The process involves complex federal and state laws, strict filing deadlines, and specific immunity protections that shield police officers from certain types of lawsuits.
At Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez & Fattell, we’ve successfully represented clients in police negligence cases throughout New Jersey. We’ll help you understand your rights and chart the legal process to hold law enforcement accountable when they’ve failed to meet their duty of care.
Table of Contents
Understanding Police Negligence Claims

Police negligence claims arise when law enforcement officers fail to perform their duties according to established standards, resulting in harm or damage to civilians.
These claims require specific elements to establish liability and overcome qualified immunity defenses.
Types of Police Negligence
Law enforcement negligence manifests in five primary forms:
- Failure to protect citizens from known threats or dangers.
- Improper vehicle pursuit procedures result in accidents or injuries.
- Inadequate response to emergency calls or reported crimes.
- Mishandling of evidence or crime scene contamination.
- Insufficient supervision or training of officers leads to preventable incidents.
The attorneys at Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez & Fattell specialize in identifying these specific types of negligence cases in New Jersey jurisdictions.
Duty of Care Requirements
Police officers maintain distinct legal obligations to protect public safety:
- Responding to emergency calls within department-established time frames.
- Following proper arrest and detention protocols.
- Maintaining accurate records of incidents and evidence.
- Protecting individuals in custody from harm.
- Upholding department policies during pursuits and confrontations.
Courts evaluate this duty of care standards based on specific state statutes and department regulations.
In New Jersey, Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez & Fattell attorneys analyze each case against established legal precedents to determine the use of care violations.
Legal Requirements for Suing Law Enforcement

Police negligence lawsuits require specific legal elements to establish a valid case against law enforcement agencies or individual officers.
The following criteria outline the essential requirements for pursuing legal action.
Establishing Police Liability
To establish police liability, you must demonstrate that officers breached their duty of care through negligent actions or inactions.
Valid claims include excessive force during arrests, failure to respond to emergency calls, improper training leading to misconduct, or inadequate security measures at public events.
Documentation of injuries, damages, or losses resulting from police negligence strengthens your case.
Video evidence, witness statements, medical records, and police reports establish a direct connection between officer conduct and your damages, which is vital when you wish to sue the police.
Qualified Immunity Explained
Qualified immunity protects police officers from civil lawsuits unless their actions violate “clearly established” constitutional rights.
Courts evaluate whether a reasonable officer understood their conduct violated these rights at the time of the incident.
Recent data shows courts dismissed 57% of qualified immunity cases between 2017-2021, highlighting the challenges faced when attempting to sue the police.
To overcome qualified immunity, you must demonstrate the officer’s actions matched previous court precedents where constitutional violations occurred.
Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez & Fattell attorneys analyze qualified immunity defenses to identify viable legal strategies for New Jersey clients.
Steps to File a Police Negligence Lawsuit

Filing a lawsuit against the police for negligence involves a systematic process requiring attention to detail.
The attorneys at Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez & Fattell guide clients through each crucial step to build strong cases against law enforcement misconduct.
Gathering Evidence and Documentation
Documentation forms the foundation of a police negligence lawsuit. Collect police reports, witness statements, and medical records from injuries sustained during the incident.
Take photographs of any physical injuries, property damage, or the scene where the incident occurred.
Preserve video footage from surveillance cameras, bodycam,s or cellphones.
Maintain detailed notes about the incident including dates, times, and, badge numbers of officers involved. The legal team at Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez & Fattell assists clients in organizing this critical evidence to strengthen their cases.
Meeting Filing Deadlines
State laws establish strict deadlines for filing police negligence claims. New Jersey requires filing a Notice of Claim within 90 days of the incident, which is crucial for those looking to sue a police department.
Federal Section 1983 civil rights claims carry a 2-year statute of limitations from the date of the incident, making it possible to sue the police if the criteria are met.
Administrative claims against government agencies mandate filing within 6 months, which is an important step before you can sue a police department.
Missing these deadlines bars recovery of damages regardless of case merit. Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez & Fattell track all filing deadlines meticulously to protect clients’ rights to compensation.
Common Challenges When Suing Police
Suing police departments for negligence involves navigating complex legal barriers and procedural requirements that can make it difficult to sue without the help of a law firm. Several significant challenges exist that impact the success of these cases.
Overcoming Qualified Immunity
Qualified immunity protects police officers from civil lawsuits unless their actions vviolateclearly established constitutional rights.
To overcome this defense, plaintiffs must demonstrate that the officer’s conduct matches previous court precedents where similar behavior was ruled unconstitutional.
The Supreme Court’s interpretation of qualified immunity requires specific evidence showing the officer knowingly violated established laws at the time of the incident.
Burden of Proof Issues
The burden of proof in police negligence cases demands substantial evidence to demonstrate liability against the defendant.
Plaintiffs must establish four essential elements to effectively sue a police department for negligence.
- The officer owed a duty of care.
- The officer breached that duty.
- Direct causation between the breach and injuries.
- Measurable damages resulted from the breach.
Statistics indicate that only 4% of excessive force complaints against police officers result in disciplinary action, highlighting the challenge of meeting evidentiary standards.
Expert attorneys at Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez & Fattell analyze evidence meticulously to build compelling cases that meet these stringent requirements.
Potential Damages and Compensation
Police negligence lawsuits provide opportunities to recover both economic and non-economic damages when law enforcement actions cause harm.
Economic Damages
Economic damages encompass tangible financial losses from police negligence. These include medical expenses for treating immediate injuries plus ongoing rehabilitation costs.
Lost wages due to inability to work during recovery or permanent disability qualify for compensation.
Property damage from police actions like broken doors during raids or vehicle damage in pursuits merit reimbursement.
Additional recoverable costs include legal fees defense costs prescription medications transportation expenses to medical appointments.
Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez & Fattell meticulously document all economic losses to maximize compensation for their New Jersey clients who may need legal advice on how to sue a police department.
Non-Economic Damages
Non-economic damages address intangible losses from police misconduct. These compensate for physical pain emotional distress mental anguish loss of enjoyment of life anxiety depression sleep disorders post-traumatic stress.
Recent data shows ntthatn-economic damages in police misconduct cases average $347,500 with settlements ranging from $25,000 to $2 million.
Damage calculations factor in severity duration permanence of psychological trauma loss of relationships altered quality of life.
Expert testimony from mental health professionals strengthens claims for these damages which Lord, Kobrin, Alvarez & Fattell leverage to build compelling cases.
Conclusion
Suing police for negligence is a complex legal process that requires careful consideration of various factors and strict adherence to filing deadlines.
While it’s possible to pursue legal action against law enforcement you’ll need strong evidence documentation and expert legal guidance to chart the challenges successfully.
With qualified immunity and other legal barriers protecting officers understanding your rights and building a compelling case is crucial.
Working with experienced attorneys who specialize in police negligence cases can significantly improve your chances of receiving fair compensation for both economic and non-economic damages.
Recall that each case is unique and success depends on thorough preparation proper documentation and timely action. Don’t hesitate to seek legal counsel to protect your rights and hold law enforcement accountable for negligent actions, as it is often difficult to sue without proper guidance.
Also Read:
Our dedicated team is ready to fight for your rights.
908-232-7666TAP TO CALL